SuperCoach Scores Twitter SuperCoach Scores Facebook

View Poll Results: Which of the following apply to your current team? (multiple choice)

Voters
238. REGISTER to Vote.
  • Starting with Libba (no Crouch or JOM)

    92 38.66%
  • Starting with Libba + Crouch (no JOM)

    69 28.99%
  • Starting with Libba + Crouch + JOM

    15 6.30%
  • Full GnR (no mid pricers)

    19 7.98%
  • GnR + Libba (1 mid pricer in Libba only)

    44 18.49%
  • Set and forget rucks

    97 40.76%
  • Ruck cover (R/F in your forwardline)

    45 18.91%
  • Spending big (starting 3 or more of Shaw/Fyfe/Goldy/Lids/Joey)

    37 15.55%
  • Spending less (starting 1 or less of Shaw/Fyfe/Goldy/Lids/Joey)

    70 29.41%
  • I will be starting with all 4 of Fyfe/ Ablett/Pendles/Rockliff

    46 19.33%
  • Planning to start a POD no one has spoken about

    43 18.07%
Multiple Choice Poll.
Page 69 of 69 FirstFirst ... 195966676869
Results 1,361 to 1,379 of 1379

Thread: Rate My Team

  1. #1361
    150 Games Club
    Join Date: 28-02-2013
    Posts: 863
    Likes: 147
    Rep Power: 2531


    0 Not allowed!

    Hi everyone i would appreicate your feedback on the best team

    team a
    shaw, rance, sheridan, dea, weitering, hartly, adams, brown

    fyfe, danger, pendles, ablett, rockie, mills, oliver, kennedy, gresham, hewett, davis
    goldie, gawn, wyatt
    barlow, martin, hall, wells, meadue, kerridge, mccarthy, amt

    team b
    shaw, rance, sheridan, BARTEL, weitering, hartly, adams, brown

    fyfe, danger, LIBBA, ablett, rockie, mills, oliver, kennedy, gresham, hewett, davis
    goldie, gawn, wyatt
    barlow, martin, hall, wells, meadue, kerridge, mccarthy, amt

    Team c
    shaw, rance, BARTEL, dea, weitering, hartly, adams, brown

    fyfe, danger, pendles, ablett, rockie, mills, PETRACCA, kennedy, gresham, hewett, davis
    goldie, gawn, wyatt
    barlow, martin, hall, wells, meadue, kerridge, mccarthy, amt

    ***changes are in capitals**

    thanks everyone

  2. #1362
    350 Games Club
    Join Date: 20-05-2014
    AFL Club: St Kilda
    Posts: 1,652
    Likes: 2,142
    Rep Power: 5551


    1 Not allowed!

    Quote Originally Posted by FirstTimer View Post
    Await your reply Zimmer ,solve my questions and it's worth a couple of coldies.......lol , that's how desperate it's getting .
    I have taken out Collins and put in Dea and moved Brown to bench with Hartley ,so the ones not playing are Hartley (D), Hibberd (M) , Cox (R) and Grimley (F)
    Your simplest fix, if you're happy keeping Hibberd as an FD, is to move him to DEF in place of Hartley, fill that MID spot with Hewett and replace Grimley with McGovern or Papley. You lose your link between DEF and MID for now, but you can get that back when you're upgrading.

    Forget about replacing Cox. There's no one.

    If it were my team, I'd be finding $120k to do the same moves but with B. Kennedy and W. Milera instead of Hewett and Papley/McGovern. I'd probably do that by downgrading Shaw, but others would do it differently.

  3. #1363
    150 Games Club
    Join Date: 11-02-2014
    AFL Club: Collingwood
    Posts: 963
    Likes: 370
    Rep Power: 2572


    0 Not allowed!

    Quote Originally Posted by Adrenaline View Post
    Hi everyone i would appreicate your feedback on the best team

    team a
    shaw, rance, sheridan, dea, weitering, hartly, adams, brown

    fyfe, danger, pendles, ablett, rockie, mills, oliver, kennedy, gresham, hewett, davis
    goldie, gawn, wyatt
    barlow, martin, hall, wells, meadue, kerridge, mccarthy, amt

    team b
    shaw, rance, sheridan, BARTEL, weitering, hartly, adams, brown

    fyfe, danger, LIBBA, ablett, rockie, mills, oliver, kennedy, gresham, hewett, davis
    goldie, gawn, wyatt
    barlow, martin, hall, wells, meadue, kerridge, mccarthy, amt

    Team c
    shaw, rance, BARTEL, dea, weitering, hartly, adams, brown

    fyfe, danger, pendles, ablett, rockie, mills, PETRACCA, kennedy, gresham, hewett, davis
    goldie, gawn, wyatt
    barlow, martin, hall, wells, meadue, kerridge, mccarthy, amt

    ***changes are in capitals**

    thanks everyone
    Hi Adrenaline ,
    IMO i would take :

    Defence : Take team B
    Mids : Take team A
    Ruck : Take as is A B & C as is
    Forwards: Take team A B & C as is

    Your R/F look like your happy with as they are in all 3 teams and don't know how much cash you have left to change anyone in either line , hope that helps a little , good luck with it.
    Last edited by FirstTimer; 25-03-2016 at 11:02am.
    SuperCoach:  ?????? (2016)  8956 (2015)  2167 (2014)  N/A (2013)  N/A (2012)  N/A (2011)  N/A (2010) 


  4. #1364
    150 Games Club
    Join Date: 11-02-2014
    AFL Club: Collingwood
    Posts: 963
    Likes: 370
    Rep Power: 2572


    0 Not allowed!

    Quote Originally Posted by stephen View Post
    Your simplest fix, if you're happy keeping Hibberd as an FD, is to move him to DEF in place of Hartley, fill that MID spot with Hewett and replace Grimley with McGovern or Papley. You lose your link between DEF and MID for now, but you can get that back when you're upgrading.

    Forget about replacing Cox. There's no one.

    If it were my team, I'd be finding $120k to do the same moves but with B. Kennedy and W. Milera instead of Hewett and Papley/McGovern. I'd probably do that by downgrading Shaw, but others would do it differently.
    So far removed Cox and replaced with Grimley , Changed Cox to McGovern and does anyone knows his JS ?? , so only have Hartley and Hibberd not playing , does anyone know of a M/D playing that could replace Hibberd and that would just leave Hartly , essendon people willl he play soon ???
    SuperCoach:  ?????? (2016)  8956 (2015)  2167 (2014)  N/A (2013)  N/A (2012)  N/A (2011)  N/A (2010) 


  5. #1365
    Rising Star Winner
    Join Date: 04-02-2013
    AFL Club: Adelaide
    Posts: 206
    Likes: 131
    Rep Power: 1199


    0 Not allowed!

    Quote Originally Posted by Zimmer View Post
    Reckon I need to free up some cash to fit in rookies and have some space for corrections. Where/who do I downgrade, if anyone? Obviously Ruggles needs upgrading - he's just holding his the position. Am I trying too hard to fit all the expensive rookies in? Thanks for any feedback.

    D: Laird, Simpson, Bartel, Longeran, Brown, Adams (AMT, Ruggles)
    M:Fyfe, Danger, Pendles, Ablett, Rockliff, Mills, Oliver, Menadue, (Gresham, Hewett, Davis)
    R:Goldy, Gawn (Wyatt)
    F:Martin, Barlow, Hall, Wells, Bennedy, Kerridge (McCarthy, Uber)
    Hi zimer are teams are quite similar, but have uber in def with Hartley was thinking of downgrading Pendles to Sidebottom and Hartley to Dea. Or should I just hold and hope Hartley gets games?
    SuperCoach:  15289 (2017)  2443 (2016)  14079 (2015)  17773 (2014) 


  6. #1366
    Rising Star Winner
    Join Date: 31-01-2014
    AFL Club: Hawthorn
    Posts: 369
    Likes: 496
    Rep Power: 2581


    0 Not allowed!

    D: Laird, Gibson, Bartel, Sheridan, Weitering, (Oscar McDonald,Adams, AMT)
    M: Danger, Pendles, Ablett, Sam Mitchell, Rockliff, Liberatore, Brad Crouch, Petracca (Menadue, Gresham, Davis)
    R:Goldy, Gawn (Loersch)
    F:Barlow, Hall, Wells, Bennedy, Kerridge (Papley, Brown)

    Would appreciate any feedback

    Still time to upgrade Petracca to Hewett (but loosing Menadue emergency points)
    and Papley to Uber
    Last edited by Presto; 25-03-2016 at 4:22pm. Reason: Bloody autocorrect
    SuperCoach:  12621 (2017)  1799 (2016)  36059 (2015)  54421 (2014) 


  7. #1367
    Vice Captain
    Join Date: 10-02-2014
    AFL Club: Essendon
    Posts: 4,452
    Likes: 2,734
    Rep Power: 4674


    0 Not allowed!

    Quote Originally Posted by craig freer View Post
    Hi zimer are teams are quite similar, but have uber in def with Hartley was thinking of downgrading Pendles to Sidebottom and Hartley to Dea. Or should I just hold and hope Hartley gets games?
    I wouldn't trade Pendles to Sidebottom, or Hartley to Dea.

    So out of those options I'd say stick with Hartley, but I'm also trying to find better option. Very difficult this year.
    SuperCoach:  352 (2016)  5675 (2015)  5778 (2014) 

    2017 Coach of: Led Zimmermen X (SCS - Division 1)

    Highest Position: 301 - Rd 16 Season 2016

    Put the pointy pencil in the pepper po.

  8. #1368
    Vice Captain
    Join Date: 10-02-2014
    AFL Club: Essendon
    Posts: 4,452
    Likes: 2,734
    Rep Power: 4674


    0 Not allowed!

    Is Bennedy to McCarthy a silly downgrade?
    SuperCoach:  352 (2016)  5675 (2015)  5778 (2014) 

    2017 Coach of: Led Zimmermen X (SCS - Division 1)

    Highest Position: 301 - Rd 16 Season 2016

    Put the pointy pencil in the pepper po.

  9. #1369
    Vice Captain
    Join Date: 10-02-2014
    AFL Club: Essendon
    Posts: 4,452
    Likes: 2,734
    Rep Power: 4674


    0 Not allowed!

    Quote Originally Posted by Zimmer View Post
    Reckon I need to free up some cash to fit in rookies and have some space for corrections. Where/who do I downgrade, if anyone? Obviously Ruggles needs upgrading - he's just holding his the position. Am I trying too hard to fit all the expensive rookies in? Thanks for any feedback.

    D: Laird, Simpson, Bartel, Longeran, Brown, Adams (AMT, Ruggles)
    M:Fyfe, Danger, Pendles, Ablett, Rockliff, Mills, Oliver, Menadue, (Gresham, Hewett, Davis)
    R:Goldy, Gawn (Wyatt)
    F:Martin, Barlow, Hall, Wells, Bennedy, Kerridge (McCarthy, Uber)
    bump. Any feeback welcome.
    SuperCoach:  352 (2016)  5675 (2015)  5778 (2014) 

    2017 Coach of: Led Zimmermen X (SCS - Division 1)

    Highest Position: 301 - Rd 16 Season 2016

    Put the pointy pencil in the pepper po.

  10. #1370
    Dual Best & Fairest
    Join Date: 18-06-2012
    AFL Club: Melbourne
    Posts: 3,236
    Likes: 1,077
    Rep Power: 4037


    1 Not allowed!

    Quote Originally Posted by Zimmer View Post
    Reckon I need to free up some cash to fit in rookies and have some space for corrections. Where/who do I downgrade, if anyone? Obviously Ruggles needs upgrading - he's just holding his the position. Am I trying too hard to fit all the expensive rookies in? Thanks for any feedback.

    D: Laird, Simpson, Bartel, Longeran, Brown, Adams (AMT, Ruggles)
    M:Fyfe, Danger, Pendles, Ablett, Rockliff, Mills, Oliver, Menadue, (Gresham, Hewett, Davis)
    R:Goldy, Gawn (Wyatt)
    F:Martin, Barlow, Hall, Wells, Bennedy, Kerridge (McCarthy, Uber)
    How much cash do you have Zimmer?

    You already have Mills, Oliver, Menadue and Kennedy. Which other expensive rookies were you looking at bringing in?

    Only real option isvto downgrade in Mids or Rucks.
    SuperCoach:  2263 (2017)  8447 (2016)  292 (2015)  3718 (2014)  3958 (2013)  731 (2012) 

    Coach of the Mighty Goulburn Valley Vikings (SCDL 2015 Premiers and SCDL 2014 Div 2 Runners-up)

  11. #1371
    Rising Star Nominee
    Join Date: 20-01-2016
    AFL Club: Collingwood
    Posts: 89
    Likes: 28
    Rep Power: 54


    0 Not allowed!

    is this team too midpriced? I originally had Fyfe and Libba in the midfield but have gone off Libba and am pretty bullish on both Wines and Shiel this season. But with a few midpriced or risky selections in the forwards and backs I feel like it might be a bit too much.


    Def: Laird Bartel Rich Lonergan Dea Tippa - Brown Adams

    Mid: Pendles Ablett Danger Rockliffe Shiel Wines Mills Gresham - Hewitt Dunkley Davis

    Ruck - Nic Nat Martin - Grimley

    Forward: Barlow Gray Hall Wells Menadue Kerridge - Mcarthey Papley
    SuperCoach:  5935 (2016)  4433 (2015)  944 (2013)  AFL Dream Team:  173 (2016) 


  12. #1372
    350 Games Club
    Join Date: 20-05-2014
    AFL Club: St Kilda
    Posts: 1,652
    Likes: 2,142
    Rep Power: 5551


    1 Not allowed!

    Quote Originally Posted by Zimmer View Post
    Is Bennedy to McCarthy a silly downgrade?
    Not silly. I personally don't want to rely on McCarthy on field, but doubt it's a killer if you do.

  13. #1373
    Dual Best & Fairest
    Join Date: 12-04-2014
    AFL Club: Collingwood
    Posts: 3,242
    Likes: 1,858
    Rep Power: 6563


    1 Not allowed!

    Quote Originally Posted by Fiasco View Post
    is this team too midpriced? I originally had Fyfe and Libba in the midfield but have gone off Libba and am pretty bullish on both Wines and Shiel this season. But with a few midpriced or risky selections in the forwards and backs I feel like it might be a bit too much.


    Def: Laird Bartel Rich Lonergan Dea Tippa - Brown Adams

    Mid: Pendles Ablett Danger Rockliffe Shiel Wines Mills Gresham - Hewitt Dunkley Davis

    Ruck - Nic Nat Martin - Grimley

    Forward: Barlow Gray Hall Wells Menadue Kerridge - Mcarthey Papley
    I think your team is more mid-priced than I would ideally like, although to answer your question - no, I don't think it's too mid-priced. I've definitely seen teams with more mid-pricers, and some very good coaches are using a similar structure and some similar selections. So it's probably very viable, just not my preference

    One thing I would say is that I'd be very surprised if Rich outscores Libba by 15ppg, yet that's what their pricing currently reflects. Shiel/Wines to Libba, and Rich to proper premium, would be a significant improvement in my view.
    SuperCoach:  589 (2016)  3225 (2015)  8243 (2014)  AFL Dream Team:  397 (2016) 


  14. #1374
    Dual Best & Fairest
    Join Date: 12-04-2014
    AFL Club: Collingwood
    Posts: 3,242
    Likes: 1,858
    Rep Power: 6563


    1 Not allowed!

    Quote Originally Posted by Zimmer View Post
    Reckon I need to free up some cash to fit in rookies and have some space for corrections. Where/who do I downgrade, if anyone? Obviously Ruggles needs upgrading - he's just holding his the position. Am I trying too hard to fit all the expensive rookies in? Thanks for any feedback.

    D: Laird, Simpson, Bartel, Longeran, Brown, Adams (AMT, Ruggles)
    M:Fyfe, Danger, Pendles, Ablett, Rockliff, Mills, Oliver, Menadue, (Gresham, Hewett, Davis)
    R:Goldy, Gawn (Wyatt)
    F:Martin, Barlow, Hall, Wells, Bennedy, Kerridge (McCarthy, Uber)
    Hi Zimmer - options I can see to raise cash would include:

    - Least favourite of the big five to Libba/Crouch type.
    - Maybe Oliver to Petracca.
    - Hall to rookie (eg Milera). I would have said Dusty, but he's locked in, and Barlow and Wells are locks in my view. You're running deeper than many up forward as a result of all of this, though - so Hall may be less needed given that, and the depth of the forward rookies.
    - Laird to Smith (I have both, but prefer Smith).

    You could also move Uber back for Ruggles (severing the D-F link for now) and bring in another forward rookie.
    SuperCoach:  589 (2016)  3225 (2015)  8243 (2014)  AFL Dream Team:  397 (2016) 


  15. #1375
    Rising Star Nominee
    Join Date: 20-01-2016
    AFL Club: Collingwood
    Posts: 89
    Likes: 28
    Rep Power: 54


    1 Not allowed!

    Quote Originally Posted by Darkie View Post
    I think your team is more mid-priced than I would ideally like, although to answer your question - no, I don't think it's too mid-priced. I've definitely seen teams with more mid-pricers, and some very good coaches are using a similar structure and some similar selections. So it's probably very viable, just not my preference

    One thing I would say is that I'd be very surprised if Rich outscores Libba by 15ppg, yet that's what their pricing currently reflects. Shiel/Wines to Libba, and Rich to proper premium, would be a significant improvement in my view.
    Hi Darkie, thanks for the reply. I think your right and that is definitely the safer option. The questions I'm asking myself are 1. Is Libba worth it if he only averages 90 and 2. Which defender to chose? The only one I'm really confident on is Shaw and he's just so overpriced. But the team definitely looks more balanced that way.
    SuperCoach:  5935 (2016)  4433 (2015)  944 (2013)  AFL Dream Team:  173 (2016) 


  16. #1376
    250 Games Club
    Join Date: 13-03-2012
    AFL Club: Adelaide
    Posts: 1,265
    Likes: 807
    Rep Power: 1991


    1 Not allowed!

    Quote Originally Posted by Zimmer View Post
    bump. Any feeback welcome.
    IMO It's that extra forward premium restricting you but Dusty is now locked in.

    You also don't have Shaw.

    I think you have to start Hall. So to me that leaves Laird. I'd suggest Laird/Ruggles for low $400k/Dea
    SuperCoach:  2252 (2017)  1238 (2016)  3623 (2015)  737 (2014)  2166 (2013)  15055 (2012)  3207 (2011)  3009 (2010)  356 (2009) 

      Quote Quote

  17. #1377
    Rising Star Nominee
    Join Date: 25-01-2015
    AFL Club: Essendon
    Posts: 136
    Likes: 42
    Rep Power: 719


    1 Not allowed!

    DEF: Shaw, Houli, Laird, Johannisen, Weitering, Dea (Adams, McDonald-Tipungwuti)
    MID: Fyfe, Ablett, Priddis, Rockliff, Wells, Mills, Parish, Kerridge (Hewett, Davis, Gresham)
    RUC: Goldstein, Gawn (Grimley)
    FWD: Martin, Barlow, Hall, Simpkin, Kennedy, Menadue (McCarthy, Brown)

    Only got $10k left over so any thoughts on this final team would be good!

  18. #1378
    Rising Star Nominee
    Join Date: 14-01-2016
    AFL Club: Collingwood
    Posts: 174
    Likes: 84
    Rep Power: 1399


    0 Not allowed!

    My final side barring late changes.

    DEF- Boyd, Bartel, Lonergan, Weitering, Dea, Brown (Adams, Uber)
    MID- Fyfe, Dangerfield, Ablett, Pendlebury, Rockliff, Libba, Mills, Oliver (Menadue, Gresham, Davis)
    RUCK- Goldstein, Gawn (Goetz)
    FWD- Barlow, S Gray, Hall, Wells, B Kennedy, Kerridge (Tippa, McCarthy)

    Originally had Currie and Hartley over Dea and Goetz. Love Uber's loophole capabilities and if I've missed a cheapie/fallen gun (Dunkley, Hewett, Parish, Papley, B Crouch) it allows me to use a sideways trade without the risk of getting rid of a guy with a negative breakeven.
    Heath Shaw and Dustin Martin will hopefully be my first upgrades.
    SuperCoach:  3692 (2015) 

      Quote Quote

  19. #1379
    400 Games Club
    Join Date: 30-06-2012
    AFL Club: Brisbane
    Posts: 1,877
    Likes: 986
    Rep Power: 2303


    1 Not allowed!

    All those sides that looked awesome turned out not so good really, hey?
    SuperCoach:  9401 (2016)  1219 (2015)  2093 (2014)  902 (2013)  8057 (2012) 

    Rat, Ox, Tiger, Rabbit, Dragon, Snake, Horse, Goat, Monkey, Rooster, Dog, Pig
    Number 1 in China

Page 69 of 69 FirstFirst ... 195966676869


Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •