SuperCoach AFL 2024 round 7 trade guide: Top targets and new dual-position players
Rookies and mid-pricers are on the chopping block in SuperCoach this week. Who needs to go and who should stay? Experts rate the most traded players this week.
Al Paton,
Tim Michell,
Dan Batten, Patch and Tarquin Oakley
17 min read
April 23, 2024 - 12:14PM
News Corp Australia Sports Newsroom
There are big decisions to make in SuperCoach, and we don’t have much time.
Round 7 starts on Wednesday night when Melbourne and Richmond meet in the annual Anzac Eve game.
Which rookies should we buy, which value premiums can we trust – and which cash cows are ready to cash in?
See our experts’ verdict on the 10 most traded in and 10 most traded out players, and scroll down for the full round 7 trade guide.
MOST TRADED IN
1. HUGO GARCIA $117,300 MID/FWD
Al Paton: BUY. No.1 rookie target this week. Saints have a few players to come back in but I think Ross will back him in.
Tim Michell: BUY. Twenty-three centre bounces, 16 tackles and 18 contested possessions in five quarters is some way to start your career. Should be coming in to any serious side.
Dan Batten: BUY. Has attended 23 centre bounces in 1.5 games and showed some good signs in a dirty night for his side last week.
Tarquin Oakley: BUY. Role is great. Score of 69 in a side that lost by 10 goals is very promising, and it could have been more if not for an early 50m penalty given away.
Patch: BUY: I don’t think we’ll want Hugo on field, and he’ll be sub here and there I reckon, but by gum he’s the best guy we’ve got this week.
2. SAM WALSH $576,800 MID
AP: BUY. I said I wanted to see one more game to be convinced – consider me sold. Back issues still worry me but value and scoring power are worth the risk.
TM: BUY. I’m too scared of breaking him as a Carlton supporter but you shouldn’t be. He could be $620k next week after scores of 166 and 130.
DB: BUY. Including the finals last year, his past five scores are 111, 134, 121, 166 and 130 at an average of 132.4. Seriously underpriced.
TO: BUY: Backed up his mammoth first game with another big score to make sure you can trust him.
Patch: BUY: I love value and Sam Walsh is value.
3. BIGOA NYUON $123,900 FWD
AP: CONSIDER. We need downgrade options but Biggie might not last long in the Kangaroos side with Kallan Dawson a week or two away.
TM: PASS. I bought him after one game and am not even convinced he holds his spot this week. He looked a bit lost at times against Hawthorn. Gut says Toby Pink comes back in.
DB: CONSIDER. Got better as the game went on but he is no certainty to hold his spot.
TO: PASS: Smart call to have waited a week on Biggy, who put up a score of 46 on the weekend. If he plays he’ll make some money but his job security is shaky.
Patch: PASS: I’ve had a successful season avoiding the entirety of the North Melbourne backline (Sheez excepted). I’ll give Biggy a miss.
4. RILEY GARCIA $125,200 FWD
AP: WAIT. Was putting up huge VFL numbers before cracking the seniors, but with Bevo it always pays to play it safe. Top rookie target for next week.
TM: PASS. Only one game in and he’s got Luke Beveridge as coach. Have another look with Tom Liberatore back.
DB: WAIT. Impressive first game but it’s hard to trust Bevo with anything.
TO: WAIT. Even if he was on the bubble you can’t be sure of anything when Luke Beveridge is coach. So at least wait until after his second match.
Patch: PASS. I don’t want a bar of a Dogs rookie coming off one game. No thank you.
5. JORDAN DAWSON $533,600 MID
AP: CONSIDER. As cheap as he’ll get (Break Even 73) but I would like to see him do it again against * checks fixture * North Melbourne. If you’re a believer, jumping on now could pay off big time.
TM: BUY. But only if you already have Walsh. The 168 was glorious but he didn’t hit triple figures in the first five rounds. Plus, Matt Crouch is back this week to take midfield minutes.
DB: CONSIDER. Walsh looks a better option and I’d want to see how he goes with Matt Crouch back. But he could go large again against North Melbourne.
TO: WAIT: A great game but those who have owned Dawson this year can tell you that it’s only his first ton of the season. If he goes big again with Crouch in the side he will still be a value trade in next week.
Patch: CONSIDER. I think he’s back? Maybe? I’d want one more look with Crouch in the side but admire anyone with the gall to go this week.
6. KANE McAULIFFE $117,300 MID
AP: BUY. Big junior numbers and will get midfield minutes in a decimated onball brigade.
TM: CONSIDER. Want to see the final Richmond team before saying yes with talk Hopper and Prestia could return. If that happens, McAuliffe might be sub.
DB: CONSIDER. Watch team sheets with Jacob Hopper back, but he looks to have done enough to get at least another week.
TO: PASS: Hasn’t put up a decent score as yet. Happy to see how he goes against Melbourne with Jacob Hopper set to return as well.
Patch: BUY. Sure. He seems like he’s got better job security than Garcia and Biggy.
7. JACK MACRAE $480,000 MID/FWD
AP: BUY. Who else are we picking at F4-6? Macrae is a long-time favourite, that’s a great price and I don’t expect Libba’s return to impact his role much.
TM: PASS. I want to see him score well with Tom Liberatore in the side before committing. Happy to pay a bit more next week if need be.
DB: CONSIDER. I’d be tempted to have another look, but $480k is good buying even with Bevo.
TO: CONSIDER: Some thought he would be F1 in pre-season so to pick him up at $480k is worth the consideration. How will he go with Libba back?
Patch: PASS. No thank you dawg. Not yet, anyway. He might be super cheap but you’re handing Luke Beveridge a loaded gun and telling him not to shoot you.
8. DAN HOUSTON $597,600 DEF
AP: CONSIDER. A likely top-six defender but I have the value guys as higher priorities this week.
TM: BUY. He has been my No.1 target for this round for weeks and I threw a tantrum on Saturday when he stuffed my plans by scoring 141. St Kilda pays little attention to half-backs and Houston hasn’t gone below 100 yet. Let’s hope I don’t break him like I did Jack Steele.
DB: BUY. Super consistent and looks a certain top-six defender.
TO: BUY. Takes kick-ins and racks up plenty of ball.
Patch: BUY (AS LONG AS YOUR NAME ISN’T TIM MICHELL). To any friendly souls reading, Dan Houston has been excellent and is coming up against the best team in the comp if you’re a running defender who likes scoring SuperCoach points. To any Tim Michell, Devourer of SuperCoach Premiums reading, there ain’t no Dan Houston here and there never was.
9. NICK DAICOS $577,300 DEF/MID
AP. BUY. Starting without him has proved to be the smart play but I’d be finding a way to get him in STAT.
TM: BUY. Whether it’s because you traded him out or never owned Daicos, now is the time to get on. Back to his best in round 6 and only likely to get better. Anzac Day Medal?
DB: BUY. An absolute bargain at that price.
TO: BUY: Your top priority if you don’t have him.
Patch: BUY. He’s back, in pog form. Get on before he gets too expensive – a priority over anyone else on this list.
10. DAYNE ZORKO $547,100 MID/FWD
AP: PASS. Can’t trust a 35-year-old with a history of soft-tissue injuries.
TM: PASS. Dayne and I have a chequered SuperCoach history so I won’t be going there. I’d much rather Macrae or even Shai Bolton. But when Zorko went on a run of 150s a few years ago I chose Bolton over him, so what do I know?
DB: CONSIDER: Pricey, but in this current role he should be a top-six if he can stay on the park. But as we have seen with Zorko, that’s a big if.
TO: BUY: With a lack of premium forward options, Zorko has a great role off half-back and didn’t get thrown forward even with Zac Bailey out.
Patch: CONSIDER. I’ve been tempted by Zork for a month now and it hasn’t quite lined up to trade him in. This is our last chance to do so before his price is sky-high, but with McKenna back this week and Zorko being 35, I’m still nervous.